Frappe Technologies
Screenshot 2023-10-25 at 10.48.41 PM.png
Money, power and open source
Because there are some things money can't buy
author

By

Rushabh Mehta

·

14 August 2024

·

5

min read

Why open source?

Even after 16 years of open sourcing ERPNext, the most common question I get asked is “Why open source?”. Maybe open source is still enough of a rarity in today’s world that people feel curious about it. Why would this company give away their software for free? What is the catch? Are they for real? Are they gypsies?

My answer to this question over the years has been ambiguous. Not everything you do has a clear answer, sometimes you just follow a hunch just because it feels right without knowing why. Over the years, I have asked this question to myself several times and because I did not have an original answer, I keep finding newer insights on why it “feels right”.

Unlike most people, my brush with open source wasn’t with Linux, but with Python programming language. I grew up in the 90s working on Microsoft based tools - mostly BASIC, and enjoyed it. There was a certain “consistency” to the user interface that I feel sadly lacking in today’s world. Also BASIC had no brackets. When I first bumped into Python, I was working on a complex project in Java. So when I saw Python, the lazy elegance of the language was love at first sight. And no brackets. Then I discovered that Python was free. At the same time, I bought an iBook (early version of MacBook) on student discount and the only way I could program on that was Python.

Python opened me to the world of “community made” software - that did not require licenses or purchasing. Yes there was Java, but Java sucked. Thinking about NetBeans and Eclipse still makes me cringe. No one would use it for a “hobby” project. It was during that time (2005) I started writing the early version of what is now Frappe Framework, as a hobby project, and I was pulled into this world of open source creativity. Also as far as I remember, web frameworks have always been free and open source (it was the time of Zope and CGI, early days for Flask). So it became a default decision for me to put Frappe Framework free as well.

In other ways, open source appealed to my sensibilities as well. Coming from a “poor” country like India which was just rising up from centuries of inequality, keeping things open made sense. My family was mostly apolitical but we subscribed to the socialist, liberal ideology of the times. So even in that sense, there was never a conflict between open source and socialism.

Later as I decided to become an entrepreneur, I could see open source as a competitive advantage in the market. In the early 2010s, “cloud” and “SAAS” were the emerging business models for software and I thought open source did not have any conflict with that either.

At the time, the open source world was divided into two competing ideologies exemplified by Linus Torvalds (moderate) and Richard Stallman (extreme). I clearly fell in the “moderate” camp. The only book I had read on the topic was Linus’ memoir - Just for Fun and it kind of summed up my feelings as well. My personality also aligns with this “devil may care” attitude, where you don’t take things too seriously, and do things for a reason, not an outcome. Like Linus, I also have a tendency to express things as I see it without caring for its political correctness or impact (It is more ethical in my point of view. Sugar-coating and self-censorship beyond a point feels manipulative).

So yes, for more reasons than one, open source just “felt right”.

Money, power and open source

Later in life as I delved more into philosophy, I realise that the organising force of society is power. People seek money not only because they seek comfort, but because they seek power. Power means the ability to change society - the ability to influence large outcomes. Money can buy you advertising and advertising can buy you influence. Our need for power is almost altruistic, we think we know better for society. The discovery of the process of how we acquire power is what gives us the moral authority. Power allows you to “control” people around you to behave in a way you think is right for the system. Power is also how you get respect in society. People are attracted to powerful people, because they want some of it rub on them and to feel powerful themselves.

In a society where most things happen via capitalism, money can get you more power than anything else. Money can be traded for almost anything - political power, fame, respect. In this context, open source feels very counter intuitive. By giving away money, it feels that you are giving away power (at least on the surface of it). And only a fool would give up power.

So why do people have a glint in their eyes when they want to know about “why open source?”. You can feel their full attention as you begin to frame your answer. It feels like they are seeking something. It is almost like you have the “power” at the moment because you have something they want. This is something I had not thought about until recently. Open source has the power of renunciation. You have ultimate power over something when you are willing to give it up, because it loses the power to affect you. This is what people want to know about - the power of open source and why does it feel more powerful than money.

If you look at society from the lens of power and not money, then it makes complete sense. Ultimately what makes us happy as humans is what will be good for me and for society. Open source is definitely good for society. Open source may not buy you comfort (you will still need money for that), but it will definitely buy you power. You may lose a bit of money in the process, but it does not seem a bad trade-off.


Photo credit

Published by

Rushabh Mehta

on

14 August 2024
10

Share

Add your comment

Success!

Error

Comments

F
Fatih Gunes

· 

August 19, 2024

I feel that OSS thrives on the fragility of human existentialism. On one hand, we want to live forever, so we seek things and power. On the other hand, we know our time is limited, so we want others (the community) to carry on. I think open source fits perfectly within this context!

M
Mania

· 

August 17, 2024

By freely sharing knowledge and tools, we contribute to a larger community and reshape our understanding of true success. This approach not only empowers individuals but also drives collective progress. Truly inspiring and thought-provoking.

N
Naveen

· 

August 16, 2024

Open source is driven by countless 'invisible hands' that keep the software economy afloat. And a handful of them are championing the way you are doing it.

In OSS, we see altruistic behavior of the highest order at the libraries/packages/frameworks level. However, there's a dramatic and stepp drop in this behavior when it comes to user-facing applications. Any insights from your journey on why creators tend to think this way?😊

J
JayaPrakash J

· 

August 15, 2024

Freedom is Power. 🔥 People love power, and a person who is free from the constraints of society is looked upon by others as powerful. Either you have enough money to influence everything or you renounce everything such that it never affects you.

Open Source is Freedom. Liberation from the constraints of the capitalist mindset. And Freedom is Powerful. 😎 ..... But all things said, you still need money to feed yourself. Contributing to open source is fine, but there needs to be more incentive for the average middle-class mind to pursue it.

R
Rajesh

· 

August 14, 2024

Great Blog !!! I always admire your Journey, thoughts and actions and try to follow them Thanks a lot for Rishab!!! Let your journey continue in right and wise path as always !!

A
Anshul Khare

· 

August 14, 2024

Useful insights on power equation.

Pardon me for being a nitpicker, there's a minor typo in this sentence. "So why do people have a glint in their eyes when the want to know about" --> when they want

U
Umar

· 

August 14, 2024

Great! It is a answer to all my questions.

M
Muchai Gateru

· 

August 14, 2024

Captures the essence of it. Your writing is so good, one just flows through the piece because of it. For the message, one has to reread the piece.

C
CA. B.C.Chechani

· 

August 14, 2024

Well communicated, Rushabh; I got clarity about your vision for Open Sourec and hope so many like me.

Arun Mathai K

· 

August 14, 2024

Great read :)

Discussion

image7f7d4e.png

Paul Mugambi

·

3 days

ago

Beautiful read, and an insight into an individual I respect and have learned a lot from. Am inspired to trust the process and never give up.

image4c43d6.png

Anna Dane

·

5 days

ago

I must say this is a really amazing post, and for some of my friends who provide Best British Assignment Help, I must recommend this post to them.

Add your comment

Comment